Past Film/Video | Documentaries

Laura Mulvey and Mark Lewis

Disgraced Monuments (1991–93)

Stream

A warehouse full of old Soviet monuments, with a statue of Lenin at the center of the shot

Stream this Wex-supported essay film exploring the fall of the Soviet Union through the systematic dismantling of its monuments. The 27-year-old project offers a compelling mirror to today’s removal of public statues in the wake of the Black Lives Matter movement.

Disgraced Monuments was filmed in Moscow and Saint Petersburg (then Leningrad) in 1991 and 1992 and edited in the Wexner Center’s Film/Video Studio in the fall of 1993. In the nearly 100 years of Russian and Soviet history that filmmakers Laura Mulvey and Mark Lewis cover in the video, successive waves of iconoclasm have left a trove of relics—dismantled and often partially destroyed monuments—that memorialize the nation’s various political regimes. Now mostly hidden away in museums, warehouses, and studios, these objects occupy a curious, almost undefinable place in post-Soviet Russian culture. Are they painful reminders of oppression? Or an important part of cultural heritage? Can they be both?

These questions are complicated by the strong symbolic value of the very act of removing a monument, which has a particular resonance in the United States of 2020. In the video, we see footage of the celebratory dismantling of a statue of Felix Dzerzhinsky, founder of the infamous Soviet secret police, broadcast around the world; the moment becomes emblematic of the end of that state. But the filmmakers remind us that history is cyclical: Dzerzhinsky himself was a revolutionary, part of a regime that systematically tore down religious iconography and monuments to czarist rule. As a Russian art critic interviewed in the film asserts, “all successful revolutions end with statues coming down.”

But perhaps statues coming down can signal the beginning of a revolution as well. While there have long been heated debates in United States over Confederate monuments and symbols, it is only in the wake of recent protests against police brutality (and particularly the murder of George Floyd by a Minneapolis officer in May 2020) that there has been a systematic call for their removal. And that call has sounded globally as monuments that have legitimized colonialist history around the world have been brought down. Is their dismantling a signal that the world is changing? One would hope, but there is much work yet to be done. As an art historian in the film notes, “it’s easier to struggle with monuments than with concrete reality.” (48 mins., video)

Jennifer Lange
Curator, Film/Video Studio Program

A warehouse full of old Soviet monuments, with a statue of Lenin at right

Image courtesy of the artists

About the artists

Program Support

MADE POSSIBLE BY
Greater Columbus Arts Council
Ohio Arts Council
American Electric Power Foundation
The Columbus Foundation
Institute of Museum and Library Services
Nationwide Foundation

ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PROVIDED BY
Huntington Bank
Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams
Kaufman Development
Cardinal Health Foundation

 

Close

Past Film/Video

Laura Mulvey and Mark Lewis